The Lying Game: Inspired by the Sara Shepard book series of the same name, The Lying Game follows long-lost twins Emma and Sutton. Separated under mysterious circumstances, Sutton was adopted by the wealthy Mercer family in Phoenix, while Emma grew up in the foster system. When the twins reunite as teenagers, they initially keep it a secret. But as the truth begins to be revealed, danger looms for everyone involved.
With all the truth coming out, the twins finally reveal themselves to their father, Ted.
Dan suspects that Theresa's investigation in the Derek Rogers murder led to foul play.
Emma's plan to prove that Sutton and Rebecca are working together backfires.
Laurel winds up in the hospital after suspecting that Sutton has a secret.
Sutton’s back in her old life, causing trouble to derail Kristin and Ted’s reconciliation.
Rebecca orders Sutton to take back her life from Emma once Kristin and Ted make strides towards reconciliation.
Ethan turns in a plagiarized paper bringing him closer to Sutton, while Emma gets closer to Thayer.