Ben seeks a hard-to-get toy for Emma's first Christmas.
Emma gets baptized while the Wheelers try to pretend to be a happy, normal family. Ben asks Riley to choose Emma's godfather.
Megan's dog is stolen, and Riley tries to get her old job back.
Ben encourages Riley in her latest attempts to pass the bar exam, and Bonnie learns that Amy has taken a pregnancy test.
Riley is ready to perform her duties as maid of honor to Katie, while Ben decides to spice up the wedding.
Ben attempts to get his father to join everyone for Emma's first Christmas photo; Tucker and Riley discover Danny's high-school journal.
Tucker's girlfriend makes Ben's life miserable, and Danny tries to set Riley up with a teammate.
A "super mom'' inspires Ben to clean up his act; Emma's grabby hands get Bonnie and Riley in trouble for shoplifting.
Riley plays a grieving widow after her boyfriend's death, and Ben is smitten with his girlfriend.
Ben and Tucker date the same woman; Riley gives Danny tips for public speaking; Bonnie tries her luck at online dating.
Ben thinks his neighbor has stolen one of Emma's favorite toys; Riley's mom visits.
Ben and Tucker pretend to be a gay couple.
Riley becomes the captain of Ben's softball team, but takes the job too seriously; Bonnie goes out with Danny's hockey coach.
A potential new boss believes Ben is married to Riley.
Ben has a thing for Tucker's co-worker, and Danny starts seeing a shrink.
Bonnie's presence is disruptive to the men.
The boys get a new neighbor. Danny mixed messages give Milena the wrong idea.
Ben and Emma's nurse have a connection; Bonnie and Tucker destroy Danny's good-luck charm.
Ben takes the lead on an endorsement opportunity for Danny.
Ben thinks Riley is dating a married man, and Danny accidentally sends a voicemail to Riley.
Miscommunication between Ben and the guys causes their ``foolproof' baby-sitting schedule for Emma to fall apart.
A 20-something bachelor bartender becomes an unlikely parent when an ex-girlfriend leaves a baby girl on his doorstep.
Ben kissed another girl at the wedding, and Riley is convinced that he's "that guy."